Are 1:1s confidential?

You’re having a 1:1 and someone brings something to you that feels like it needs addressing with someone else. Maybe they’re having a problem with a teammate. Maybe they’ve been approached about a new role. What do you do? Is the discussion confidential, even if they didn’t ask you to keep it so?

Mark Rabkin, VP Engineering and Product Facebook said, "If it’s safe enough to be overheard — it’s not the right content for a 1:1." The very idea of a 1:1 is to talk about things that shouldn’t be discussed in groups. Confidentiality is a requirement.

Skip-level 1:1s are almost always complaint sessions, often about their boss or teammates. You have to keep them 100% confidential. This is hard because it often feels like you need to fix things. You’re the manager after all, and what is your job there for if not to fix things? You must resist this urge. If the team doesn’t feel they can tell you things without it getting out, they will hold back, and you’ll miss out on the benefits of the skip levels.

If Carly tells you she’s thinking of applying for a spot somewhere else in the company, you can’t go tell her boss about it or your trust is blown and the skip levels become useless.

You often have to avoid taking direct action after a 1:1, so you don’t inadvertently leak what was talked about. Evan tells you that his boss is taking forever to approve the latest plans, you’ll have to wait a while to talk about it with his boss, or he’ll think Evan tattled on him.

In 1:1s with your own reports, they’re talking to their boss, so they have an absolute expectation of privacy. Unless you specifically talk to them about bringing someone else into the discussion, their thoughts and concerns should stay completely between the two of you. If you find that you’re regularly talking bringing something up with someone else, then you either have a seriously dysfunctional company, or you’re talking about the wrong things in your 1:1s (hint: stop talking about the work you’re doing).

Of course, if something illegal or unethical is going on, address it right away. Take whatever steps you can to sanitize the source, but you can’t allow bad behavior to continue.

This is one of a series of posts about holding 1:1s. View the rest of the series.


Your comments:

Text only, no HTML. URLs will automatically be converted to links. Your email address is required, but it will not be displayed on the site.

Name:

Not your company or your SEO link. Comments without a real name will be deleted as spam.

Email: (not displayed)

If you don't feel comfortable giving me your real email address, don't expect me to feel comfortable publishing your comment.

Website (optional):

Follow me on Twitter

Best Of

  • How not to apply for a job Applying for a job isn't that hard, but it does take some minimal effort and common sense.
  • Movie marketing on a budget Mark Cuban's looking for more cost effective ways to market movies.
  • California State Fair The California State Fair lets you buy tickets in advance from their Web site. That's good. But the site is a horror house of usability problems.
  • Customer reference questions. Sample questions to ask customer references when choosing a software vendor.
  • Comment Spam Manifesto Spammers are hereby put on notice. Your comments are not welcome. If the purpose behind your comment is to advertise yourself, your Web site, or a product that you are affiliated with, that comment is spam and will not be tolerated. We will hit you where it hurts by attacking your source of income.
  • More of the best »

Recently Read

Get More

Subscribe | Archives

Recently

Assumptions and project planning (Feb 18)
When your assumptions change, it's reasonable that your project plans and needs change as well. But too many managers are afraid to go back and re-work a plan that they've already agreed to.
Feature voting is harmful to your product (Feb 7)
There's a lot of problems with using feature voting to drive your product.
Encouraging 1:1s from other managers in your organization (Jan 4)
If you’re managing other managers, encourage them to hold their own 1:1s. It’s such an important tool for managing and leading that everyone needs to be holding them.
One on One Meetings - a collection of posts about 1:1s (Jan 2)
A collection of all my writing on 1:1s
Are 1:1s confidential? (Jan 2)
Is the discussion that occurs in a 1:1 confidential, even if no agreed in the meeting to keep it so?
Skip-level 1:1s are your hidden superpower (Jan 1)
Holding 1:1s with peers and with people far below you on the reporting chain will open your eyes up to what’s really going on in your business.
Do you need a 1:1 if you’re regularly communicating with your team? (Dec 28)
You’re simply not having deep meaningful conversation about the process of work in hallway conversations or in your chat apps.
What agenda items should a manager bring to a 1:1? (Dec 23)
At least 80% of a 1:1 agenda should be driven by your report, but if you also to use this time to work on things with them, then you’ll have better meetings.

Subscribe to this site's feed.

Contact

Adam Kalsey

Mobile: 916.600.2497

Email: adam AT kalsey.com

Twitter, etc: akalsey

Resume

PGP Key

©1999-2019 Adam Kalsey.